August 10, 1926: Pauline Wants to Move to New York!

“Father, I am leaving for the United States!” Pauline, my twenty-year-old daughter, doesn’t beat around the bush. It isn’t even “I would like to”—no: she wants to.

“But with what money, my dear?” I retorted, believing I held the ultimate argument to hold her back.

She then detailed the savings she had patiently set aside working as a nurse alongside her medical studies. Above all, Pauline stressed her need for a change of scene, to indulge in astronomy—her passion—in a city like New York that is captivated by science, and to complete her medical degree in an environment far more welcoming to women than our French faculties. She is already dreaming of reaching out to Columbia’s astronomy department or attending public lectures at the American Museum of Natural History, while hoping to join the College of Physicians and Surgeons or Cornell’s medical school. She insists she can live on “next to nothing,” that her English is perfectly respectable, and that, in any case, her mind is made up.

My wife, with whom she had already discussed the matter, wholeheartedly supports the initiative: “Olivier, I assure you, it is a wonderful thing for her. Pauline is radiant. Let us let her fly the nest!”

It is true. Never has my daughter’s gaze revealed such a blend of determination, serene happiness, and steadfast confidence in the future.

It now falls to me to reach out to a few well-placed contacts to keep her from lodging in the metropolis’s unsavory quarters—such as the infamous surrounds of Hell’s Kitchen or the Bowery—and to ease her parents’ minds. I am thinking in particular of my former chief Clemenceau, who lived over there for a long time, is perfectly bilingual, and knows the Roosevelt family well. I could also reach back out to Margaret L. Hayes, the diplomat from the U.S. Embassy with whom I had an interview the other day, couldn’t I?

The main ward of an American hospital in the 1920s

An operating room in an American hospital in the 1920s

The Historian’s Corner

Studying Medicine as a Woman in New York in 1926:

In France, medical studies had been open to women since the late 19th century, but the academic environment remained steeped in conservatism. In the United States, the situation evolved more rapidly in certain major institutions: Cornell University Medical College had been coeducational since its founding in 1898, and Columbia University’s College of Physicians and Surgeons opened its doors to female students in 1917. Furthermore, New York hospitals offered significant clinical internship opportunities for female practitioners.

Astronomy in New York Before the Hayden Planetarium:

In 1926, New York was buzzing with scientific excitement. The American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) was the beating heart of popular astronomy thanks to Dr. Clyde Fisher, who brought together enthusiasts and academics for highly sought-after public lectures (he would go on to found the Amateur Astronomers Association the following year). At Columbia, the astronomy department was undergoing major modernization: Pupin Hall and its Rutherfurd Observatory were under construction at the time and would open in 1927.

Crime and Safety in New York Under Prohibition:

Since the implementation of the Volstead Act in 1920, the sale of alcohol had been illegal in the United States. By 1926, organized crime (led by figures such as Lucky Luciano, Meyer Lansky, and Frankie Yale) controlled the city. Neighborhoods like Hell’s Kitchen (the stronghold of Irish gangs controlling the docks) and the Bowery (riddled with speakeasies, illegal gambling, and tensions in nearby Chinatown) were considered particularly dangerous for a young woman on her own.

Georges Clemenceau and His American Network:

The “Tiger” knew the United States intimately, having lived there from 1865 to 1869. While there, he worked as a correspondent for the newspaper Le Temps, taught French at a girls’ school in Stamford, Connecticut, and married an American woman, Mary Plummer. Fluently bilingual, he maintained influential political and diplomatic connections there, notably within Theodore Roosevelt’s circle.

10 août 1926 : Pauline veut s’installer à New-York !

« Papa, je vais partir pour les États-Unis ! » Pauline, ma fille de vingt ans, n’y va pas par quatre chemins. Ce n’est même pas « je souhaite », non : elle veut.

« Mais avec quel argent, ma chérie ? » rétorqué-je, pensant tenir là l’argument ultime pour la retenir.

Elle me détaille alors les sommes qu’elle a patiemment mises de côté en travaillant comme garde-malade en parallèle de ses études de médecine. Pauline insiste surtout sur son besoin de changer d’air, de s’adonner à l’astronomie — sa passion — dans une ville comme New York qui se passionne pour la science, et d’y achever son cursus médical dans un environnement bien plus ouvert aux femmes que nos facultés françaises. Elle rêve déjà d’approcher le département d’astronomie de Columbia ou d’assister aux conférences publiques de l’American Museum of Natural History, tout en espérant intégrer le College of Physicians and Surgeons ou l’école de médecine de Cornell. Elle affirme qu’elle peut vivre « avec presque rien », que son anglais est très correct et que, de toute façon, sa décision est prise.

Ma femme, avec laquelle elle a déjà eu cette conversation, soutient pleinement l’initiative : « Olivier, je t’assure, c’est une excellente chose pour elle. Pauline est rayonnante. Laissons-la sortir du nid ! »

C’est vrai. Le regard de ma fille n’a jamais révélé un tel mélange de détermination, de bonheur paisible et de ferme assurance face à l’avenir.

Il me reste à solliciter quelques relations facilitatrices pour lui éviter de loger dans les secteurs peu recommandables de la métropole — comme les environs malfamés de Hell’s Kitchen ou du Bowery — et tranquilliser ses parents. Je pense notamment à mon ancien patron Clemenceau, qui a longtemps vécu là-bas, est parfaitement bilingue et connaît bien la famille Roosevelt. Je pourrais aussi recontacter Margaret L. Hayes, la diplomate de l’ambassade des États-Unis avec laquelle j’ai eu un entretien l’autre jour ?

Une salle d’opération dans un hôpital aux États-Unis dans les années 20

La grande salle d’un hôpital américain dans les années 20

Le coin de l’historien

 Étudier la médecine en tant que femme à New York en 1926 :

En France, les études médicales sont ouvertes aux femmes depuis la fin du XIXᵉ siècle, mais le milieu universitaire reste imprégné de conservatisme. Aux États-Unis, la situation évolue plus vite dans certaines grandes institutions : le Cornell University Medical College est mixte depuis sa fondation en 1898, et le College of Physicians and Surgeons de Columbia University a ouvert ses portes aux étudiantes en 1917. Les hôpitaux new-yorkais offrent en outre d’importantes opportunités d’internat clinique pour les femmes praticiennes.

 L’astronomie à New York avant le planetarium Hayden :

En 1926, New York est en pleine effervescence scientifique. L’American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) est le cœur battant de la vulgarisation astronomique grâce au Dr Clyde Fisher, qui réunit passionnés et universitaires lors de conférences publiques très courues (il fondera l’Amateur Astronomers Association l’année suivante). À Columbia, le département d’astronomie est en pleine modernisation : le bâtiment Pupin Hall et son observatoire Rutherfurd sont alors en chantier et ouvriront leurs portes en 1927.

 L’insécurité new-yorkaise sous la Prohibition :

Depuis la mise en œuvre du Volstead Act en 1920, la vente d’alcool est illégale aux États-Unis. En 1926, la pègre organisée (emmenée par des figures comme Lucky Luciano, Meyer Lansky ou Frankie Yale) contrôle la ville. Des quartiers comme Hell’s Kitchen (fief des gangs irlandais contrôlant les docks) ou le Bowery (maillé par les speakeasies, le jeu clandestin et les tensions de Chinatown) sont réputés particulièrement dangereux pour une jeune femme seule.

 Georges Clemenceau et son réseau américain :

Le « Tigre » connaît parfaitement les États-Unis pour y avoir vécu de 1865 à 1869. Il y a exercé comme correspondant pour le journal Le Temps, enseigné le français dans un collège de jeunes filles à Stamford (Connecticut) et épousé une Américaine, Mary Plummer. Parfaitement bilingue, il y a conservé d’importants relais politiques et diplomatiques, notamment auprès du cercle de Theodore Roosevelt.

August 1, 1926: Nothing Must Go Off the Rails in the Mines!

The soap in the great earthenware washbasin can do nothing about it. This coal dust, fine and clinging as chimney soot, stays lodged beneath my nails and in the creases of my palms. However hard I scrub, it wins out: it settles into the grain of the writing paper on which I set down these lines, in small black traces I no longer dare wipe away.
Looking at them, I measure the distance that separates the plush carpets of the Rue de Rivoli from the bottom of Pit 11.
Raymond Poincaré has sent me to the North with a fixed idea in mind: to determine whether our coal basins can bear the strain of the monetary war effort without tipping the country into a general strike. Tonight, in the silence of this room at the Hôtel de la Gare in Lens, where one can still almost hear, far off, the panting of a coal convoy, I have my answer.


This Morning’s Descent
Nothing prepares you for the cage as it drops. We say “go down” — the word is far too gentle. It is a controlled fall, four hundred metres down a black shaft, the stomach lurching upward, and then, all at once, the stop, the silence, and that damp heat seizing you by the throat like a hand. The air is thick with dust and sweat; the lamp at the belt pierces no more than a metre ahead of one’s feet.
Walking before me is Henri de Peyerimhoff, president of the Comité Central des Houillères — that great jurist out of the Conseil d’État who has become the true spokesman of the mining employers. He advances without a moment’s hesitation into the darkness, as though he knew every gallery by heart. Peyerimhoff wished to show me “his place of work” before any discussion took place, “so that I might see for myself,” as he put it.
Rounding a coalface, we come upon three men, bare-chested, their skin gleaming, black with coal down into the very creases of their wrinkles. Two young Poles, arrived on recent convoys of the Société Générale d’Immigration, and a strapping local lad, native to Lens or Hénin. Together, muscles straining to breaking point, they heave forward a tram wagon of at least five hundred kilos, on makeshift rails, in a grinding of iron that all but drowns out their breathing.
It is this force — raw, silent — that drives the entire economy of the country, and that one so easily forgets from behind a desk in Paris.


The Tram Wagon
Then, with a metallic crash that echoes down the whole gallery, the wagon jumps its rails. The mass of iron tips dangerously, threatening to fall upon the legs of one of the Poles, who struggles to hold it back. The shift foreman comes running and shouts an order — which the man, not understanding a word of French, cannot carry out. I see the miners’ eyes harden around us; something, in the already unbreathable air, grows taut.
It is here that Peyerimhoff shows his true face. He does not lose his temper. The former magistrate lays a firm hand on the foreman’s shoulder and says, without raising his voice, with a cold authority sufficient to cut the panic short:
“Calm yourselves. The language barrier calls for method, not shouting. If this wagon overturns, or a man is hurt, we lose two hours of output, and we sow resentment for months to come.”
With a gesture, he sends for a bilingual worker. Within barely two minutes, the order is translated, the wagon righted and set back on its rails, and work resumes — quietly, almost as though nothing had happened. Only the men’s eyes, still a shade too fixed, say otherwise.


Black Coffee
Back at the surface, in the management office, over a black and bitter coffee that strikes me as the best I have tasted in weeks, the exchange remains grave. Peyerimhoff pushes the production ledgers toward me, then fixes me with that lucid, almost weary gaze worn by men accustomed to carrying heavy decisions alone:
“You see it for yourself, Monsieur le Conseiller. Discipline is not maintained through threats. If we want the mines to supply the coal needed to stabilise the Franc, these men must be treated with method and with justice. Safety in the coalfaces, decent wages, respect for the contracts of our immigrants: these are not concessions. They are the very conditions of productivity.”
“That is precisely the analysis of the cabinet in Paris, Monsieur de Peyerimhoff,” I reply. “The State will lend its support for transport and equipment. But we shall be inflexible on the protection of the miners and the enforcement of the rules. We shall not save the currency on the backs of the men from the pit.”
He nods, satisfied, it seems, to find that the government yields neither to demagogy nor to old-style employer brutality.


Night Over the Slag Heaps
It is late now. Through my window, the slag heaps cast enormous shadows into the northern night, like black hills set down there by mistake. I return to Paris tomorrow, still a little dust beneath my nails, with a certainty that will not leave me: with men of Peyerimhoff’s calibre, a pact of reason between the State and heavy industry is possible.
Whether it will hold, once I am gone, remains to be seen.

« Rounding a coalface, we come upon three men, bare-chested, their skin gleaming, black with coal down into the very creases of their wrinkles. Two young Poles, arrived on recent convoys of the Société Générale d’Immigration, and a strapping local lad, native to Lens or Hénin. »
„Walking before me is Henri de Peyerimhoff, president of the Comité Central des Houillères — that great jurist out of the Conseil d’État who has become the true spokesman of the mining employers.“

Propulsé par WordPress.com.

Retour en haut ↑